A tax-return fee and a year-round accounting service are different purchases. Put responsibilities, included work and additional charges in writing before comparing totals.
An accountant's monthly price can cover anything from a narrowly defined year-end task to ongoing recordkeeping and support. Before comparing fees, establish which work you need and which work you will continue to do yourself. Otherwise, two apparently similar packages can allocate hours of work to different people.
This guide is for UK sole traders comparing professional services. It does not calculate your tax or determine your filing obligations. Ask a suitably qualified adviser about the requirements that apply to your circumstances, including changes in the business or reporting system.
Give the same business brief to each firm
Describe the business activity, approximate transaction volume, number of bank or payment accounts, current recordkeeping method and whether records are up to date. Identify staff, overseas transactions or other features that you want the firm to assess. State uncertainty rather than guessing a classification to obtain a quote.
Explain the starting point: setting up a new arrangement, preparing a return from organised records, or repairing a backlog. Catch-up work is not automatically part of a routine annual price. Ask each firm what records it needs to confirm the scope and which items remain provisional.
ICAEW's small-business guide to hiring an accountant encourages considering the support required and checking appropriate professional membership. Confirm experience with the type of work you need, rather than treating a familiar job title as a complete assessment of suitability.
Divide the work into named tasks
| Work area | Question to settle |
|---|---|
| Bookkeeping | Who enters and categorises transactions, and how often? |
| Reconciliation | Who checks records against bank and payment accounts? |
| Year-end work | Which accounts, schedules and returns are included? |
| Other reporting | Which applicable services are included or separately quoted? |
| Advice and support | What questions, meetings or response arrangements are covered? |
| Software | Who pays, owns access and exports records on departure? |
Use the table to identify responsibilities, not to assume you need every service. A well-defined lower-cost package can be appropriate if you can perform the excluded work accurately and on time. If you cannot, ask for the cost of including it before selecting the package.
Read the fee arrangement with the scope
ICAEW's fee-information guidance addresses written fee arrangements, estimates and the basis of charging for its members. Ask for an engagement letter that matches the proposal you compared, including tax treatment and the process for approving additional work.
Distinguish a fixed fee for specified work from an estimate based on assumed record quality or volume. If a package has limits, ask how extra transactions, late records or additional meetings are charged. “Unlimited support” needs an explanation of what kind of support, through which channels and during what period.
For hourly work, ask what tasks are expected, who will perform them and when a revised estimate will be provided. An hourly rate alone does not establish the likely cost of your assignment.
A fictional annual-cost comparison
Suppose Firm A offers £40 per calendar month, plus £300 for the agreed annual return work. Its quoted annual service cost is £780. Firm B offers £70 per calendar month including that same work, totalling £840. Assume for this example that both totals include any applicable VAT and cover the same twelve months.
If A also requires a software subscription costing £10 per month that B includes, the comparable totals become £900 and £840. These are invented amounts for illustration, not typical accountant fees or a claim that either pricing model is better.
Check whether a monthly payment spreads an annual commitment or pays for a service that can end monthly. The payment frequency does not answer the cancellation question. Ask how fees are handled if you leave partway through the year or before a return is completed.
Agree a records and approval timetable
Write down when you must provide records, when the firm expects to prepare work and how you will review it. A firm cannot necessarily complete a task by your preferred date if essential information arrives late. Ask how missing records and unresolved questions will be escalated.
HMRC explains that you remain responsible for your own tax when using an agent. If the agent submits your return, you must check the information and confirm it is correct before submission. Keep time for that review in the schedule rather than treating the filing date as the first moment you will see the figures.
Use the proper HMRC authorisation route described for the relevant service. You do not need to hand over your personal sign-in credentials merely to request a quote. Ask how the firm securely receives records and how access is managed.
Plan the handover as well as the start
Ask what you receive at year-end and on departure: completed returns, accounts, underlying records and software exports where applicable. Clarify ownership and continuing subscription costs. A low recurring fee can be difficult to evaluate if leaving the arrangement creates an undefined handover cost.
HMRC's guide to choosing a tax agent provides further checks before appointment. Retain the accepted scope, fee schedule, responsibilities and approval record together. Our broader service-quote comparison guide can help organise the commercial terms while your adviser addresses the tax questions.
Sources & further reading
Sources checked during preparation on 21 November 2026. Check the linked source for current terms and later changes.
This guide provides general information about comparing costs. It is not personal medical, legal, financial or insurance advice. Examples are illustrative; actual quotes and terms vary. Read our editorial standards.

